AI and Health Coaching: A Threat, an Opportunity, or a Valuable Partnership?

What does the latest research tell us about the changing role of the health and wellness coach?

Artificial intelligence is hardly a novel topic anymore. This is not the first time we have written about it in this newsletter.  But it is not going away and the speed with which it is developing indicates that we need to watch carefully how it can affect our industry, our profession and us as individuals.   AI has moved well beyond something we might be curious about into something that is increasingly part of our everyday lives. Whether we embrace it enthusiastically or approach it with caution, it is undoubtedly changing the way we work, learn and communicate.

For those of us involved in health and wellness coaching, perhaps the most useful question is no longer whether AI will change our profession, but how we can use it to strengthen what we do, rather than viewing it simply as a challenge to our role.

AI already offers considerable possibilities for supporting behaviour change. It can help people track their progress, access health information, identify patterns in their behaviour and receive reminders or encouragement between appointments. For health professionals and coaches, it can assist with research, planning, developing educational resources and managing some of the administrative demands that take time away from working directly with clients.

But how does it compare with the experience of being coached by another human being? And what might this mean for the future of our profession?

Some interesting research is beginning to offer answers.

Can AI deliver the same results as a human coach?

A randomised controlled trial published in JAMA in 2025 compared an AI-powered lifestyle intervention with a traditional human-coached Diabetes Prevention Program.

The study involved 368 adults with prediabetes and overweight or obesity who were randomly assigned to either an automated AI programme or a human-led programme over 12 months.

The researchers examined outcomes including weight loss, physical activity and blood glucose regulation.

Perhaps surprisingly, the results were remarkably similar.

At the end of the study, 31.7% of participants assigned to the AI programme achieved the primary combined health outcome, compared with 31.9% of those assigned to human coaching.

The researchers concluded that the AI intervention met their predefined criteria for non-inferiority to the human-led programme.

AI participants were also more likely to begin the programme and meet its completion criteria.

These are encouraging findings. They suggest that automated, personalised support can be effective in helping people achieve measurable lifestyle changes, particularly when it is accessible and readily incorporated into everyday life.

However, an important distinction is that this particular AI intervention used personalised digital messages and behavioural prompts, rather than the conversational generative AI tools many of us now associate with ChatGPT.

And there is another important consideration: health and wellness coaching is rarely focused on achieving just one measurable health outcome.

The complexity of health and wellbeing

One of the distinguishing features of health and wellness coaching is its recognition that health is multidimensional.

Clients rarely arrive with neatly defined challenges that exist independently of everything else happening in their lives.

Someone might initially seek coaching because they want to lose weight, improve their fitness or manage a chronic health condition. Yet as the coaching relationship develops, other concerns may emerge.

They may be experiencing considerable stress, struggling with confidence, feeling overwhelmed by competing responsibilities or dealing with significant life changes. They may be lonely, socially isolated or lacking a sense of purpose.

What initially appears to be a relatively straightforward behaviour change goal can become an exploration of broader wellbeing.

This complexity matters when we interpret studies comparing AI with human coaching.

An intervention might be successful in achieving a predetermined outcome, such as increased physical activity or improved blood glucose levels. But does that tell us everything about the person’s experience, their psychological wellbeing or their capacity to manage future challenges?

Certainly not.

This doesn’t diminish the value of achieving measurable health improvements. Rather, it reminds us that the outcomes of coaching can extend considerably beyond those captured in a clinical trial.

The growing importance of human connection

There is another dimension to consider, particularly in a world where technology increasingly shapes our interactions.

In 2025, the World Health Organization’s Commission on Social Connection released a landmark report highlighting the extent of loneliness and social isolation worldwide.

It estimated that approximately one in six people globally experiences loneliness, with potentially serious consequences for physical and mental health.

Interestingly, the highest reported rates were among adolescents and young adults, challenging the assumption that loneliness is predominantly an issue associated with ageing.

The report called for social connection to be recognised as an essential component of health and wellbeing.

This is particularly relevant to coaching.

A professional coaching relationship is not a substitute for friendships, family relationships or other meaningful social connections. Nor should coaching be viewed as a treatment for loneliness.

However, being genuinely listened to, understood and supported within a trusting professional relationship can be a valuable experience in itself.

And importantly, coaching may help clients recognise a lack of connection in their lives, explore what meaningful relationships would look like for them and identify ways of strengthening their sense of belonging.

For some clients, developing healthier relationships, reconnecting with their community or finding a greater sense of purpose may become just as important as the health goal that originally brought them to coaching.

What do clients value about human coaching?

A subsequent analysis of the diabetes prevention trial, published in npj Digital Medicine in August 2026, explored how participants experienced the two approaches.

Although participants using AI engaged sooner and more consistently, those receiving human coaching reported higher satisfaction and acceptability.

Interestingly, 46.5% of participants in the AI group indicated that they would have preferred a human coach.

Another exploratory study published in the American Journal of Health Education in October 2026 examined university students’ experiences of human and AI health coaching.

Participants particularly valued human coaches for their empathy, connection, accountability and responsiveness.

However, they also appreciated AI’s accessibility, structure and non-judgemental nature.

The researchers suggested that AI could offer a useful complementary resource rather than necessarily replacing human coaching.

While this was a small study, its findings raise an interesting question.

Are we measuring everything that matters when we evaluate the effectiveness of coaching?

A person may improve their health behaviours while also developing greater self-awareness, confidence, resilience and a stronger sense of personal agency.

These changes can be difficult to capture using a narrow set of outcome measures, yet they may have considerable value for someone’s longer-term wellbeing.

Where might AI fit into this broader coaching approach?

Imagine someone who wants to become more physically active.

An AI-supported application might help them monitor their activity, identify patterns, receive reminders and celebrate their progress.  All of these may be extremely useful.

But perhaps the client continues to struggle, despite having the necessary information and resources.

Through a coaching conversation, they may begin to recognise that their real challenge is a lack of confidence, competing demands or feeling disconnected from activities and people they once enjoyed.

The focus of the conversation may shift from exercise itself to what would make life feel more satisfying, manageable or meaningful.And that may ultimately lead to sustainable changes in physical activity alongside improvements in other areas of their life.

Of course, AI can also ask reflective questions, respond supportively and help people explore their thinking. We should not underestimate how sophisticated these tools are becoming.

However, we still need to understand much more about their ability to respond safely and effectively to the complexity of individual circumstances, particularly when emotional, social and psychological challenges are involved.

An opportunity to strengthen our profession

Rather than positioning AI and human coaching as competing approaches, perhaps the greatest opportunity lies in understanding how they can complement one another.

AI may be particularly valuable for monitoring progress, providing information, supporting accountability and offering accessible assistance between coaching sessions.

Human coaches bring professional judgement, interpersonal skills and the ability to work collaboratively with clients as they navigate the interconnected dimensions of their lives.

The ethical use of technology is essential, of course. Confidentiality, informed consent, data security, accuracy and professional boundaries must all be carefully considered.

But there is little value in resisting developments that may ultimately enhance the support we can provide.

At Wellness Coaching Australia, we have always recognised that effective health and wellness coaching involves considerably more than helping someone follow a health plan.  It is about supporting people to develop awareness, confidence and the capacity to make meaningful, self-determined changes that enhance their overall wellbeing.

As AI becomes increasingly integrated into healthcare and behaviour change support, these competencies remain central to professional coaching practice.

Perhaps the future of health and wellness coaching is not about choosing between technology and human connection, but about using technology to create more opportunities for meaningful human connection.

And that is an exciting possibility.

References

Mathioudakis, N., et al. (2025). An AI-powered lifestyle intervention vs human coaching in the Diabetes Prevention Program: A randomized clinical trial. JAMA, 334(23), 2079–2089. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2025.19563

Patient engagement, acceptability, and preference of artificial intelligence versus human coaching for diabetes prevention. (2026). npj Digital Medicine. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41746-026-03063-w

Yan, Z., Benes, S., & Peacock, J. (2026). Do college students prefer AI health coaches over human health coaches? A mixed-method exploratory study. American Journal of Health Education. https://doi.org/10.1080/19325037.2026.2743610

World Health Organization. (2025). From loneliness to social connection: Charting a path to healthier societies. Report of the WHO Commission on Social Connection. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/978240112360